Fat Dan's Chicago-Style Deli, Carmel Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Fat Dan's Chicago-Style Deli, a hidden gem in Carmel, Indiana, where the vibrant flavors of Chicago find their way onto your plate. Located at 840 W Main St, this deli promises an authentic dive into culinary delights.
From their mouthwatering Stone Oven Pizzas, like the hearty Abe Froman loaded with smoked bacon and house-made meatballs, to the garlic breadsticks that pair perfectly with tangy marinara, Fat Dan's menu is bursting with flavor. Their salads, including the Chopchop, offer a fresh crunch that complements the rich and savory sandwiches.
Don’t miss the standout burgers—like the acclaimed Flat Daniel, which delivers a heavenly mix of cheese, bacon, and a luscious pink center. Customers rave about the loving service and cheerful atmosphere, making Fat Dan's not just a meal, but a memorable experience. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this deli is a must-visit!
Stone Oven Pizza
Zalinsky Pizza
House sausage, pepperoni and peppadew peppers
Abe Froman Pizza
House sausage, pepperoni, smoked bacon & house meatball
Garlic Breadsticks
With marinara
House Garlic Cheese Bread
Parmesan Garlic Butter
Starters
Salads
House Salad
Mixed greens, tomato, carrot, cucumber, -on side is balsamic vinaigrette
Chopchop Salad
Mixed greens, pepperoni, Bell pepper, red onion, mushroom, cucumber, gorgonzola
Fat Dan's Pork Sandwich
14 - hour hickory-smoked, hand-pulled, (BBQ, pickle, onion all on side)
Fat Dan's Brisket Sandwich
14 - hour hickory-smoked, sliced, dry-rubbed,-(BBQ, pickle, onion all on side)
Smokers
Fat Burgers
Fat Frenchy Burger
Smoked ham, brie, capers, spicy mustard lettuce, tomato
NY Fat Burger
Pastrami smoked corned beef, garden, swiss, spicy mustard